Trying to follow a strict minimalist approach can be overwhelming for highly sensitive introverts, so go slowly.
I used to think being a highly sensitive introvert and a minimalist went hand in hand. We need lower levels of stimulation to function at our best, which often translates to wanting less overall: less noise, fewer people, and less clutter.
I assumed having less stuff around was a natural part of high sensitivity. It took me years of trying — and failing — to “minimize” before I started to question that assumption. While there are common traits among highly sensitive introverts, I realized they manifest very differently from person to person. There’s no “right” way to be sensitive, just as there’s no “right” way to be an introvert.
So if you’re a highly sensitive introvert who has tried the whole minimalism thing and it didn’t work for you, you’re not alone. In fact, pursuing a minimalist lifestyle might be making you more stressed, not less. That doesn’t mean decluttering is out of reach, though. You may just need a different approach to get your space looking and feeling the way you want.
The Minimalist Vision
Minimalism has nearly as many definitions as there are people practicing it. At its core, minimalism is about not having more than you need. Everything serves a purpose — either it’s useful or it’s beautiful. You only keep what “sparks joy.”
Joshua Fields Millburn and Ryan Nicodemus, known as The Minimalists, offer an elevator pitch for minimalism: “A lifestyle that helps people question what things add value to their lives. By clearing the clutter from life’s path, we can all make room for the most important aspects of life: health, relationships, passion, growth, and contribution.” They add, “Getting started is as simple as asking yourself one question: How might your life be better if you owned fewer material possessions?”
These definitions leave room for any amount of stuff, as long as it’s purposeful. Yet the Pinterest-perfect vision of minimalism — purging until your home is nothing but clean lines and whitewashed colors — continues to dominate as the hallmark of a “successful” minimalist.
When I first saw that ideal version of minimalism come to life on social media, I was mesmerized. My highly sensitive, introverted brain does a happy dance whenever I see a cleared-off surface, so I thought that achieving this curated aesthetic would be my personal version of HSP nirvana.
But then came the reality of making it happen — and the even tougher question of whether it was what I actually wanted.
The Minimalism Process
The phrase “it gets worse before it gets better” perfectly describes the minimalist overhaul process most people attempt. Following the Marie Kondo method, you pull everything out of closets, drawers, and every nook and cranny, then systematically inventory every single item you own while asking yourself if you truly need it.
In theory, this approach is great — knowing what you have and where it is can reduce stress. But in practice, that level of chaos is overwhelming, especially for highly sensitive introverts who feel everything more deeply. If the overwhelm paralyzes you and prevents you from finishing, you’re left with more mess than you started with.
This scenario has happened to me more than once. On average, my family and I have moved once every two years since I got married fourteen years ago. Each time, I saw it as the perfect opportunity to pare down what we owned so there would be less to pack. While some stress came from the moving process itself, there was an entirely separate layer of overwhelm from making so many decisions — one for every single item.
I found myself endlessly debating the fate of each object, weighing sentimental value, usefulness, and cost. Yet in the back of my mind, I clung to that vision of a minimalist home, believing it could only be achieved by getting rid of as much as possible.
Eventually, my decision-making process shifted. It became less about thoughtful consideration and more about exhaustion. Getting rid of things felt like the easiest way to escape the chaos in the moment. But some of those decisions haunt me — I still think about items I gave away and wish I had kept.
What I hadn’t realized yet was how much my belongings contributed to making my home feel like home. Not the unorganized piles, but the comfort and familiarity of the books, knickknacks, and random items I had accumulated over a lifetime. When I finally asked myself what I truly needed, the answer was clear: It wasn’t minimalism.
Decluttering Tips for Sensitive Introverts
My desire to downsize and my need for a refuge still conflict at times, but with practice, I’ve found it easier to strike a balance. The strategies I’ve discovered can help you declutter your space — without sacrificing the peace it brings you.
- Start small. Even decluttering just five items a day can lead to huge progress over time without disrupting your home or life. This approach eases the pressure because you can start with the easy tosses. Plus, those small steps prevent clutter from turning into piles of trash bags sitting forlornly in the back of your closet (ask me how I know).
- Take your time with uncertain items. During a big decluttering session, it’s easy to feel a sense of urgency. Clutter that’s normally hidden away spills onto floors and surfaces, demanding immediate action. But when you’re following the “five items a day” method, you can set aside anything you’re unsure about and move on without stress. Don’t force yourself to part with something just for the sake of decluttering.
- Notice when you’re overwhelmed — and give yourself grace. Highly sensitive brains process the world differently. If sensory input is already overwhelming on a given day, it’s okay to skip decluttering. It’s not a moral failing. Remember, this process is something you’re doing for yourself, so let it work for you.
You Decide What Clutter Means in Your Refuge
For highly sensitive introverts, refuge isn’t just about being alone or enjoying quiet. It’s about having a space where we feel at ease.
Decluttering can be part of that, but so can surrounding yourself with items that bring comfort. Whether it’s a childhood stuffed animal or travel souvenirs, whatever makes you feel at home is vital to your mental health and the recharging time you need as a highly sensitive introvert.
Downsize what keeps you from relaxing, but don’t feel pressured to let go of something just because it doesn’t fit the “minimalist” ideal. You get to decide what clutter means to you.
Even if your surfaces are entirely covered in knickknacks, if your space is functional and brings you joy, then those things aren’t extraneous. Quite the opposite: They’re an essential part of your refuge. 
You might like:
Want to feel more at ease in social situations?
Discover the secrets to enjoying fun, meaningful conversations. Know exactly what to say, even if you’re introverted, shy, or anxious. Feel less drained and have more energy while socializing. Click here to secure your spot in Jenn Granneman’s upcoming course, Easy Conversation.
